The state of Georgia doesn't have the best history when it comes to Muslims (let's not forget the Georgia judge who barred hejabi women from his courtroom, and had one arrested for refusing to take it off), but this is a whole other level of discrimination and hatred. People are outraged because Muslims want to expand a mosque...
Dar-e Abbas is a mosque that holds services in a small house in the city of Lilburn. Over the years the number of attendees has grown, and they want to expand and remodel the mosque as well as add a cemetery. To do this they must have the property re-zoned from "residential" to "commercial." I think it's best now to turn to the videos showing what (apparently) happens when a property is re-zoned. The first is here, and the second here, and there is also an accompanying article found here.
Although I think all three links speak for themselves, here are a few choice quotes.
From the first video:
"I'm prejudiced, and I don't want them [Muslims] here."
"I mean, they need to just take a chill pill, so to speak, and go through the political system."
"I have a problem with it being a cemetery."
"Mosque is alright, but if they want to put a cemetery, that's no good."
The reporter says he spoke to three people "who told [him] flat out they were racist" and so did not want the mosque expanded, and when he asked why they would not say so on camera, they replied that they were "afraid their house would be burned to the ground."
From the second video:
"It doesn't have anything about, nothing to do about, umm, them [Muslims]. This is about hurting our community, this is about hurting our kids."
From the article:
"I am prejudice [sic], I just don't like Muslims and I don't want them taking over our neighborhood," said one resident who lives near the mosque. He did not want to be identified for fear of retaliation.
"I don't want someone coming to my house and burning it down."
"I don't have a problem with it being a place of faith I have a problem with it being a cemetery."
I pull these comments out with reason; I want to show how ridiculous the claim is that people are upset about re-zoning. There are so many offensive comments that it's hard to hear and appreciate them all when watching the videos, but reading them like this forces you to really understand how foul they are. These comments are reflections of ignorant and frightening Islamophobic attitudes that have absolutely nothing to do with zoning issues.
Regarding the cemetery comments - for those who understand why people would be uncomfortable with a cemetery in their neighborhood (which is the usual response I've gotten from people who I've discussed this article with), let me point out that this mosque is not located in a "neighborhood." This house is not in a small subdivision, but rather on a very long highway with a 45 mph speed limit, which runs through two counties and four cities. Still not convinced? Google Maps "Street View" shows that Lawrenceville Highway is a five lane road in front of the mosque. Not exactly a cozy neighborhood street.
If you're already planning a response explaining to me how perhaps these comments really are just people upset about a plot of land being legally zoned as one thing rather than another, I want you to imagine this article being about a church. I want you to imagine a small church wanting to expand and add a cemetery, and I want you to imagine the Muslims in the neighborhood up in arms about it. I want you to imagine Muslims discussing how they "just don't like" Christians, how they're flat out prejudiced against them and unapologetic about it. I want you to imagine them saying how they were afraid that these Christians--these clearly fanatical, backwards, frightening Christians--would come burn down their homes if they found out who they were (because only a fanatical, backwards, frightening people could be capable of such a thing). I want you to imagine a Muslim man telling the camera that these Christians just need to take a "chill pill" and "go through the political system" (as if they weren't already doing so, as if applying for re-zoning isn't exactly that). I want you to imagine a middle-aged Muslim woman telling the camera "this is about hurting our community, this is about hurting our kids."
It's rather awful, isn't it? It's not even awful as much as it is silly. It all sounds pretty silly, because it doesn't make sense. The idea of Christians not abiding by "the political system" doesn't make sense. The idea of Christians as barbarians that are capable of burning down your home doesn't make sense. The image of church-going Christians is not what one imagines when thinking about entities that hurt the community and kids.
Muslims have been so demonized in the U.S. that these statements seem plausible. They don't cause the same sort of visceral reactions you'd find if this were a group of Muslims speaking about Christians, and that's frightening.
There's so much that is so wrong with this story. Maybe the next post should be dedicated to the "reporters" covering their events and their ridiculous tone and language... "Clash of cultures"? Flashing "ANGRY PROTESTS" across the screen while showing only the Muslims? Describing people as "racist" against Muslims?(!) I don't have the emotional energy to dissect these things now though. I just want to say that you should care about this. It's clear from the reporter's comment (and from everything else produced by mainstream U.S. culture) that "Muslim" is, for many, a raced category conflating multiple ethnicities, religions, and nationalities into one identity. If you're a minority in any way there is every possibility that the same kind of dangerous "Other"-ing logic that allows thoughts like these to flourish can be (and probably already is) used against you.
Sunday, October 25, 2009
"I just don't like Muslims..."
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
"I want you to imagine this article being about a church"
Or how about a synagogue? What if the Christians in the story were still Christians, but the Muslims were Jews?
There would be rightly be no confusion about the odiousness of the whole thing then.
the only silver lining to this is that the racists admit that they're afraid of us.
for too long people of color are made to be afraid of the cops, of going into all white neighborhoods, and of being too "ethnic" in public because whitey will think that we're crazy.
run and hide, you white supremacists. we're coming to tare down your fantasy of an all white world.
Kahlil, racists are not "afraid" of you. They are too ignorant and close-minded to even know to be afraid.
Don't you see that by reviling the racists on "the other side", you are (on this blog) promoting racism yourself. I realize it's much more "newsworthy" to wave the race or religion flag, but it's just not going to help your cause one little bit, not if you really want non-Muslims to believe that Islam is a religion of peace.
You also don't seem to want to point out the facts of the situation here. If you had attended any of Lilburn City's government meetings over the 11 years this mosque has been in Lilburn, you would know that Lilburn is famous for breaking and/or bending it's own zoning rules and future zoning plans. We, the citizens in the area of Lilburn, have had an organized group to "watchdog" this behavior by the Lilburn government for almost 20 years. We organize, sign petitions and vocalize our opposition to Lilburn's Planning Commission and City Council EVERY TIME a questionable rezoning attempt is being made. It is unfortunate that this situation has been "colored" as a race or religion issue because it takes the focus away from the real "bad guys".
Anonymous - I don't necessarily agree with Khalil, but I'd hardly call what he's saying racist.
The only folks waving "the race or religion flag" are the non-Muslim residents of Lilburn. If you take a look at any of the videos or news articles posted you will see that it is Lilburn residents who are against the mosque expansion who are discussing religion and race, not mosque-goers.
If Lilburn is indeed "famous" for ignoring its own zoning rules, that's not what got them on the news. If you have a watchdog organization that truly seeks to protect the interest of Lilburn citizens against a zoning commission which regularly breaks its own rules at the cost of citizens that's great. Unfortunately, many of the Lilburn residents speaking to the media are not speaking about the zoning issues involved, nor are they claiming to be part of some watchdog organization that REGULARLY opposes potential re-zonings (not just ones involving mosques such as Dar-e Abbas and Dar-us-Salaam).
It is indeed "unfortunate that this situation has been 'colored' as a race or religion issue," but it isn't the mosque-goers doing this. Instead it is non-Muslims Lilburn residents who are saying they simply "don't like Muslims," that they are "prejudiced," that they are afraid of Muslims "taking over [their] neighborhood" and on and on. I encourage you to re-read the blog post itself instead of responding only to Khalil. I believe most of the issues you raise in your response to Khalil are discussed in the blog entry itself.
This isn't silly. This isn't silly at all.
This is heartbreaking. This is disappointing in a way I cannot describe. This quite literally has driven me to tears of frustration, anger and sorrow.
When I decided to have children I resolved to raise them to be better than this. And I am constantly surrounded by the kind of unreasoning hatred and bigotry represented by this situation all over the place.
It's not just that these people are trying to deny others the ability to show their respect for Allah in their own way. It's not just that they are being denied the ability to bury their dead in a manner they choose. It's not that they are being denied the same things that other people who happen to call God by a different name are granted without thought. It's what surrounds these denials. It's not just religion. The religion is a representation of their culture and their heritage and they are being persecuted for honoring those that came before them.
That is so wrong I can't articulate it properly.
Post a Comment